| Oliver! - Smiling Rhino Theatre Company | 62
|
| Bye, Bye Birdie - GB Productions | 61
|
| Jesus Christ Superstar - Trinity Players of Mullica Hill | 60
|
| King & I, The - Cranford Repertory Theatre Group | 59
|
| Wizard of Oz, The - Marlboro Players | 59
|
| Wizard of Oz, The - Middlesex County Plays in the Park | 53
|
| Annie Get Your Gun - Allegro Productions | 52
|
| Seussical: The Musical - Allegro Productions | 51
|
| Ragtime: The Musical - Battery Factory Theater | 49
|
| Bye, Bye Birdie - Stagecrafters Inc. | 49
|
| Carnival - SummerStage at Leonia | 48
|
| Music Man, The - Washington Crossing Repertory Company | 48
|
| Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat - HTC Productions | 48
|
| Ragtime: The Musical - Barn Theatre | 47
|
| Music Man, The - MOC Musical Theatre | 47
|
| Children of Eden - Allegro Productions | 47
|
| Carousel - Opera Theatre of TCNJ | 47
|
| Gypsy - HTC Productions | 46
|
| Oliver! - Enchanted Players | 45
|
| West Side Story - Cranford Repertory Theatre Group | 44
|
| Fiddler on the Roof - Phoenix Productions | 43
|
| Titanic: The Musical - Phoenix Productions | 42
|
| Gypsy - Off Broad Street Players | 42
|
| Music Man, The - BG Theatre Club of Morris County | 42
|
| Jesus Christ Superstar - Stagecrafters Inc. | 42
|
| Miss Saigon - Middlesex County Plays in the Park | 41
|
| Oliver! - Middlesex County Plays in the Park | 40
|
| Brigadoon - Allegro Productions | 40
|
| Music Man, The - Enchanted Players | 40
|
| Bye, Bye Birdie - BG Theatre Club of Morris County | 39
|
| Titanic: The Musical - Middlesex County Plays in the Park | 39
|
| Carousel - Battery Factory Theater | 39
|
| Ragtime: The Musical - Middlesex County Plays in the Park | 39
|
| Wizard of Oz, The - MOC Musical Theatre | 38
|
| Brigadoon - Phoenix Productions | 38
|
| Evita - Main Street Theatre Company | 38
|
| Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat - Trinity Players of Mullica Hill | 38
|
| Fiddler on the Roof - Pierrot Productions | 38
|
| Annie - Main Street Theatre Company | 38
|
| Narnia - Conservatory Players~The | 38
|
| Fiddler on the Roof - Villagers Theatre | 38
|
| Jack The Ripper - Barn Theatre | 38
|
| Jesus Christ Superstar - Road Company | 38
|
| Scarlet Pimpernel (musical), The - Pennington Players | 38
|
| Brigadoon - Main Street Theatre Company | 37
|
| Crazy for You - Allegro Productions | 37
|
| Follies - Paper Mill Playhouse | 37
|
| Chorus Line, A - Strand Theater Project | 37
|
| Narnia - Saint Genesius Players | 37
|
| Who's Tommy, The - Allegro Productions | 37
|
| Annie Get Your Gun - Battery Factory Theater | 36
|
| Annie - Hexagon Players | 36
|
| Sound of Music, The - Somerset Valley Players | 36
|
| Cabaret - North Brunswick Young Adult Drama Group | 36
|
| Peter Pan - Middlesex County Plays in the Park | 36
|
| My Fair Lady - MOC Musical Theatre | 35
|
| Annie - Allegro Productions | 35
|
| MidNightMares - Saint Genesius Players | 35
|
| West Side Story - Millennium Productions | 35
|
| High School Musical - Main Street Theatre Company | 34
|
| Christmas Carol, A - Theatre Five | 34
|
| Annie Warbucks - MOC Musical Theatre | 34
|
| George M! - Main Street Theatre Company | 34
|
| Anything Goes - Main Street Theatre Company | 34
|
| Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat - Saint Genesius Players | 34
|
| Into The Woods - Glen Ridge Theater | 34
|
| It's a Wonderful Life - Allegro Productions | 33
|
| Grease! - Belleville High School Stagecraft Club~The | 33
|
| Carousel - Cumberland Players | 33
|
| Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat - Hexagon Players | 33
|
| Anything Goes - Mystic Vision Players | 33
|
| Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat - Hexagon Players | 33
|
| Camelot - Paper Mill Playhouse | 33
|
| Urinetown - Allegro Productions | 33
|
| Hello, Dolly - Middlesex County Plays in the Park | 33
|
| Student Prince, The - Paper Mill Playhouse | 33
|
| One Night Only - Mystic Vision Players | 32
|
| Music Man, The - Monmouth County Park System Summer Theatre | 32
|
| Guys and Dolls - Battery Factory Theater | 32
|
| Jekyll & Hyde - Smiling Rhino Theatre Company | 32
|
| Kiss Me, Kate - Middlesex County Plays in the Park | 32
|
| Damn Yankees - Main Street Theatre Company | 32
|
| West Side Story - North Brunswick Young Adult Drama Group | 31
|
| Jekyll & Hyde - Pennington Players | 31
|
| Buddy Holly Story, the - Middlesex County Plays in the Park | 31
|
| Jesus Christ Superstar - Saint Genesius Players | 31
|
| Our Town - Conservatory Players~The | 31
|
| Once Upon a Mattress - NENA Productions Theater Project | 31
|
| Seussical: The Musical - Middlesex County Plays in the Park | 31
|
| Carousel - Main Street Theatre Company | 31
|
| Barnum - North Brunswick Young Adult Drama Group | 31
|
| Will Rogers Follies, The - Paper Mill Playhouse | 31
|
| Gypsy - Paper Mill Playhouse | 31
|
| Guys and Dolls - Main Street Theatre Company | 31
|
| Crazy for You - Phoenix Productions | 31
|
| Guys and Dolls - Talent Time Players | 31
|
| Midsummer Night's Dream, A - Like 40 Productions | 31
|
| Free To Be You & Me - Allegro Productions | 31
|
| American Rapture - Mystic Vision Players | 30
|
| American Rapture - Mystic Vision Players | 30
|
| How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying - Studio Players | 30
|
| 42nd Street - Allegro Productions | 30
|
| Mame - Paper Mill Playhouse | 30
|
| Annie - Saint Genesius Players | 30
|
| Tony 'n Tina's Wedding - Allegro Productions | 30
|
| Guys and Dolls - GB Productions | 30
|
| Footloose - Main Street Theatre Company | 30
|
| Merrily We Roll Along - North Brunswick Young Adult Drama Group | 30
|
| Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat - Smiling Rhino Theatre Company | 30
|
